CRA Tax Debt and Your Mortgage: Borrowing $70,839 Privately Costs $7,483 More Than Leaving It With the CRA
The fees alone on a private second come to 6.82% of the balance - nearly the whole year of CRA interest at 7.25%.
Sunday, 15 November 2026. The bottom line: CRA tax debt costs 7% compounded daily, which works out to 7.2501% a year — cheaper than every private mortgage on the market. On a $62,000 balance filed five months late, it stands at $70,839.27 today. Leaving it with the Canada Revenue Agency another year costs $5,135.92. Clearing it with a private second mortgage priced at an illustrative 10.99% costs $12,618.81 once fees are counted — $7,482.89 more. You do not borrow against your home to beat the agency's interest rate, because you cannot. You borrow to get a lien off your title before it closes every other door.
What CRA tax debt actually costs you
The Canada Revenue Agency publishes prescribed interest rates quarterly. For the quarter running 1 October to 31 December 2026, the rate charged on overdue income tax, Canada Pension Plan contributions and employment insurance premiums is 7%. The same 7% applies to overdue GST and HST remittances.
That 7% is not a simple annual rate. The agency charges compound daily interest starting the day after the due date. Compounded daily for a full year, 7% produces an effective annual cost of 7.2501%. Those 25 basis points are easy to miss and they are real.
For scale: the Bank of Canada's policy rate sits at 2.50% after the 25-basis-point increase on 28 October 2026, prime is 4.70%, and the best advertised insured five-year fixed mortgage rate is 4.44%. CRA tax debt is therefore priced about 281 basis points above the cheapest insured mortgage money in the country, and about 230 basis points above the best uninsured five-year fixed at 4.95%. Expensive, but nowhere near private territory.
The prescribed rate also resets every quarter and tracks Government of Canada yields, so the 7% charged on CRA tax debt this quarter is not locked for your whole repayment. The five-year Government of Canada benchmark closed at 3.53% on 12 November 2026, up from 3.35% on 9 November. The next Bank of Canada decision is 9 December 2026. Market expectations lean toward no near-term relief, and they change with a single data release.
The penalty is the expensive part, not the interest
CRA tax debt runs on two meters. Interest is the slow one; the late-filing penalty is the fast one. File late with a balance owing and the agency charges 5% of the balance, plus 1% for every full month the return is late, to a maximum of 12 months. If you were penalized in any of the three prior years and received a demand to file, that becomes 10% plus 2% a month, to a maximum of 20 months.
Run it against the file below. A $62,000 balance filed five full months late carries a $6,200 late-filing penalty, while the 198 days of interest to today total $2,639.27. The penalty is 2.35 times the interest. Annualized across the 198-day delay, the penalty alone costs 18.43% of the tax owing, and no mortgage product reverses it. Most CRA tax debt gets expensive at the filing deadline, not on the interest meter: filing on time and paying late beats filing late, every time.
The worked file
A self-employed borrower owns a home worth $750,000 with a $420,000 first mortgage and 22 years of amortization left. The 2025 return was filed five full months late with $62,000 of CRA tax debt. Payment was due 30 April 2026.
| Component | Amount |
|---|---|
| Tax owing | $62,000.00 |
| Late-filing penalty (5% + 5 × 1%) | $6,200.00 |
| Balance bearing interest | $68,200.00 |
| Interest, 198 days at 7% compounded daily | $2,639.27 |
| CRA tax debt owing, 15 November 2026 | $70,839.27 |
At 80% loan-to-value the refinance ceiling on this home is $600,000, leaving $180,000 of theoretical room above the existing first mortgage. The $70,839.27 fits. Whether a lender will advance it is a separate question, and that question decides everything.
Three ways to clear CRA tax debt, priced
Each route below is costed over the same twelve months on the same $70,839.27, using Canadian semi-annual compounding for the mortgage options and daily compounding for the CRA tax debt.
| Route | Twelve-month cost | Annualized |
|---|---|---|
| A. Payment arrangement, debt stays with the CRA | $5,135.92 | 7.25% |
| B. Refinance the first mortgage at 4.95% uninsured | $3,430.02 | 4.84% |
| C. Private second mortgage, illustrative 10.99% interest-only | $12,618.81 | 17.81% |
Route B rolls the balance into a new $490,839.27 first mortgage over the same 264-month amortization. The payment moves from $2,602.45 to $3,041.39, an increase of $438.94 a month, and incremental interest over twelve months is $3,430.02. Against leaving CRA tax debt where it is, refinancing saves $1,705.89 in the first year — real, and modest.
Route C is built from an illustrative private second at 10.99% interest-only with a 2% lender fee, a 2% broker fee and $2,000 of legal, appraisal and title cost. Those private figures are an illustrative assumption, not a market quote: private second pricing is negotiated per file and is not advertised anywhere you can check it. The all-in 17.81% is consistent with the arithmetic in our breakdown of what a private mortgage actually costs in Canada.
Why a private second can never win on rate
Here is the arithmetic that settles it. On a $70,839.27 balance, a 2% lender fee plus a 2% broker fee plus $2,000 of closing cost comes to $4,833.57, or 6.82% of the amount borrowed. A full year of interest on the same CRA tax debt is 7.25%.
The fees alone consume almost a full year of interest before a single day of private interest accrues. After those fees, the coupon that would tie the agency is 0.43%, and no private lender writes at 0.43%. A private second taken purely to retire CRA tax debt is a worse deal than the CRA tax debt itself, and the gap on this file is $7,482.89 in year one.
That is the opposite of how the product is sold. The pitch is that the CRA is the scariest creditor you have, so clear it first at any price. The pricing says CRA tax debt is one of your cheaper creditors.
The lien is the real deadline
So why borrow at all? Because the agency's leverage is not its interest rate. It is registration.
Before the CRA can put a lien on your home or seize anything, it must certify what you owe — it states it must legally certify the amount you owe by getting a provincial judgement or a certificate from the Federal Court, which makes the debt a matter of public record. Once certified, it can register a lien, which the agency defines as a legal claim that we put against a property to secure the payment of a debt. Registration gives it priority as a creditor: the amount comes out of your sale proceeds before you see a dollar. If a certified balance stays unpaid, a writ can direct a sheriff or bailiff to seize and sell assets.
That reframes the mortgage question. A registered lien must be paid out on any sale or refinance, and most A lenders will not fund a file with one on title. Route B, at 4.84%, is open to borrowers who move before certification and closed to many who move after. CRA tax debt becomes a private-lending problem at the moment it is registered, not at the moment it is assessed.
There is a clock in your favour. The agency's collections policy says it generally cannot begin certain legal collection actions until 90 days after it sends a notice of assessment or reassessment. That restriction does not apply where collection would be jeopardized by delay, and a court can authorize immediate action. Treat the 90 days on CRA tax debt as a planning window, not a rule you can lean on.
What to do, in order
If you are carrying CRA tax debt and own a home, the sequence matters more than the product:
- File every outstanding return now, even if you cannot pay. The penalty clock runs on filing, not paying, at 1% a month.
- Get the balance in writing from your CRA account, split into tax, penalty and interest, before you price any borrowing.
- Check what is registered on title. A title search costs a few hundred dollars and determines which of the three routes is open to you.
- Ask for a payment arrangement while you arrange financing. The agency says it will consider arrangements based on your ability to pay, and an officer may verify your income, expenses, assets and liabilities.
- Price the A-lender refinance first. At 4.84% all-in it beats both alternatives, and only before a lien lands.
- If you are self-employed, expect to document income the hard way. Our guide to qualifying for a self-employed mortgage covers what lenders ask for, and most also want proof your taxes are current.
- Treat a private second as a bridge with a dated exit, not a solution. Price the exit before you sign the entry.
- Stress-test the new payment. A 25-basis-point move on the refinanced $490,839.27 first mortgage adds $67.93 a month.
One caution on scale: rolling a tax balance into a 22-year amortization spreads a short-term cost across two decades. The same trade-off applies to any consolidation, run both ways in our piece on refinancing to consolidate debt. How the 80% ceiling and your income interact is covered in our cash-out refinance breakdown.
Common questions
Can I get a mortgage with CRA tax debt?
Often yes, but the tier depends on registration. Before a lien is registered, some A and B lenders will refinance and pay the balance out through your lawyer at closing — the cheapest route on this file at 4.84% annualized. After registration, most A lenders step back and the realistic options narrow to B and private lenders at materially higher cost.
Is it better to pay the CRA or keep the money in my mortgage?
On rate alone, CRA tax debt at 7.25% effective is dearer than mortgage money at 4.44% to 4.95% and cheaper than an illustrative private second at 17.81%. If you qualify for an A-lender refinance, paying the balance out of it saves money. If private money is your only access, borrowing to clear the balance costs more than leaving it.
How long before the CRA registers a lien on my house?
There is no published schedule. The agency generally cannot start certain legal collection actions until 90 days after a notice of assessment, and it must certify the debt in the Federal Court or obtain a provincial judgement before registering a lien. It can move faster where it believes collection is in jeopardy. In practice the window on CRA tax debt is measured in months, not years, and it closes without warning.
Rates change monthly. Your inbox should too.
One short email when the market moves — Bank of Canada decisions, bond yields, and what they mean for your renewal.
We email you once to confirm. Nothing is sent until you click it.


