Automatic Renewal: Posted Is 6.19%, the Market Is 4.95%, and Doing Nothing Costs $31,365
On a $528,000 renewal, an automatic renewal at the posted 6.19% rate costs $374.05 a month more than the best market rate — and once it takes effect, leaving costs $8,170.80.
Monday, 16 November 2026 — the bottom line. If you let your maturity date pass without signing anything, your lender renews the mortgage for you. On a $528,000 balance with 23 years left, an automatic renewal at the posted five-year rate of 6.19% costs $3,566.84 a month against $3,192.80 at the best advertised uninsured five-year of 4.95%. That is $374.05 a month, $12.30 a day, and $31,365.41 of extra interest over one five-year term. The worse part is the timing: on your maturity date, walking away is free. One day into an automatic renewal, it costs three months' interest — $8,170.80 on that balance, which is 21 months of the gap you were trying to escape.
What an automatic renewal actually is
You do not get to stop paying at the end of a term. You owe the balance. Unless you repay it in full or sign somewhere else, the mortgage continues, and every federally regulated lender has a default path for borrowers who do not reply. That path is the automatic renewal.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada is direct about it: if your lender is federally regulated it must send a renewal statement “at least 21 days before the end of the existing term,” and that statement must tell you if the renewal will be automatic. The agency's own warning is that an automatic renewal “could mean you don't get the best rate or conditions.” The statutory plumbing sits in subsection 627.89(6) of the Bank Act and section 45 of the Financial Consumer Protection Framework Regulations.
Nothing about that is a trick. The letter is real, the rate in it is real, and the lender may offer whatever rate it likes. An automatic renewal is expensive because it is the one outcome in Canadian mortgage lending that happens to you by default, and the default is never the sharpest number on the market.
The 124-basis-point gap an automatic renewal hands you
The Bank of Canada publishes what the chartered banks post for a five-year conventional mortgage. On 11 November 2026 that rate was 6.19%, and it has not moved since early October. The best advertised uninsured five-year fixed is 4.95%. The spread is 124 basis points.
| Five-year fixed, $528,000 over 23 years | Rate | Monthly | Interest over the term | Balance at term end |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Posted five-year (Bank of Canada, 11 Nov 2026) | 6.19% | $3,566.84 | $152,596.26 | $466,585.64 |
| Big Six average, discounted uninsured | 5.37% | $3,317.34 | $131,825.53 | $460,785.38 |
| Best advertised uninsured | 4.95% | $3,192.80 | $121,230.85 | $457,663.06 |
| Best advertised insured | 4.44% | $3,044.66 | $108,412.56 | $453,732.91 |
Rates are as at 13 November 2026 except the posted rate, which is the Bank of Canada's weekly series for 11 November. The Big Six average is a lender-published average rather than a quote you can book, and it sits in the table to show the middle of the market, not as a rate to aim for.
Most renewal letters do not arrive quoting 6.19%. They arrive somewhere between the posted rate and the discounted market, which is exactly why the letter looks reasonable. At this balance every 25 basis points is $73.86 a month, so a letter that is 75 basis points off the best available rate — a gap most borrowers would not blink at — is $223.96 a month and $13,437.50 over the term.
Why the cost is bigger than the payment gap
The monthly gap understates the damage, because a higher rate does two things at once. You pay more cash, and less of each payment retires principal.
Over the five-year term, the automatic renewal at 6.19% takes $22,442.83 more out of your account than the 4.95% rate. At the end of the term you also still owe $8,922.58 more, because $8,922.58 less principal came off. Those are the same $31,365.41 of extra interest seen from two sides — they should not be added together, and anyone who adds them is double-counting. One automatic renewal at posted costs you $22,443 in cash and leaves you $8,923 further from owning the house.
The asymmetry: free on the maturity date, $8,170.80 the day after
This is what makes an automatic renewal different from simply accepting a mediocre rate. On your maturity date you hold the cleanest position you will ever have. The term is over, so there is no prepayment penalty. You can move the balance to another lender, and because the loan amount and amortization stay put, federal rules let you do it without passing the stress test again — the straight switch covers how that exemption works and what it is worth.
Once an automatic renewal takes effect into a new five-year fixed term, that position is gone. Leaving early triggers a prepayment charge, and three months' interest on $528,000 at 6.19% is $8,170.80 — a year in, on the reduced balance, still $8,003.16. Set against the $374.05 you overpay each month, that charge is 21 months of the gap: you would sit in the wrong mortgage for most of two years before escaping it broke even. On a posted-rate mortgage the interest rate differential calculation may produce a larger figure still; our piece on the prepayment penalty sets out both methods.
| Leaving your lender, $528,000 at 6.19% | On the maturity date | After an automatic renewal |
|---|---|---|
| Prepayment charge | $0 | $8,170.80 (three months' interest) |
| Stress test on a straight switch | Exempt | Exempt, but the charge applies |
| Months of the $374.05 gap the charge equals | — | 21 months |
| Cost of the decision | Free | $8,170.80 |
An automatic renewal converts a free decision into an $8,170.80 decision overnight, with no document signed.
An automatic renewal cannot take effect until 21 days after the letter
Here is the provision almost nobody quotes. Section 45(1)(d) of the Financial Consumer Protection Framework Regulations requires the renewal statement to tell you that your rights under the existing agreement continue, and that the renewal does not take effect, until the later of the renewal date and the day 21 days after you receive the statement.
That cuts the opposite way to how most people assume. The 21 days are not only a notice period before maturity — they are a floor measured from receipt. If the statement reaches you nine days before maturity, the automatic renewal cannot take effect on the maturity date. Your existing terms continue until 21 days after the letter landed. A late letter does not shorten your window; it extends your old mortgage.
So keep the envelope or the email: the date you received it is the date that matters. If a lender tells you the automatic renewal is already locked because maturity has arrived, the regulation says otherwise where the statement arrived inside 21 days.
The same regulation also stops the quoted rate drifting upward: paragraph 45(1)(c) requires a statement that no change increasing your cost of borrowing will be made between the day the statement is disclosed and the renewal day. The number in the letter is a ceiling, not an opening bid that can worsen.
What to do, and when
The renewal statement is not the start of this process. Twenty-one days is not enough to gather documents, get an appraisal and close a switch. Treat the letter as the deadline for beating the automatic renewal, and start about four months out.
- At 120 days: take a rate hold. It is free at most lenders, it caps your rate while you shop, and many will still pass on a lower rate if the market falls. A 120-day hold taken now covers the 9 December Bank of Canada decision. See how rate holds work.
- At 120 days: ask your own lender for its best rate, not the renewal rate. Expect to show a competing quote.
- At 90 days: get a written comparison that nets out legal and discharge costs, so you are comparing what you actually pay. The switch-or-stay arithmetic runs that calculation both ways.
- When the statement arrives: write down the date you received it, the rate, the term, the payment and whether it says the renewal is automatic.
- At 30 days: decide. If you are switching, your new lender needs instructions to the lawyer by now.
- If maturity is closer than 21 days from the letter: say so in writing and ask the lender to confirm the date the renewal takes effect.
- If you have already been automatically renewed: ask for the exact prepayment charge in writing before assuming you are stuck, and compare it against the monthly gap over the months remaining.
One caution on the variable side. The best advertised insured five-year variable is 3.66%, or prime less 1.04% against prime at 4.70% — $2,824.90 a month here, cheaper than every fixed option above. It is also the option whose payment moves. The Bank of Canada raised the policy rate to 2.50% on 28 October and next decides on 9 December; market expectations for that decision can change, and nobody can tell you where prime sits in three years.
Common questions
Can my lender refuse to renew my mortgage?
Yes. There is no obligation to renew you. Where a federally regulated lender will not, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says it must tell you 21 days before the term ends. That is a short runway to arrange financing elsewhere — another reason to start months out rather than waiting for a letter.
Is an automatic renewal binding if I never signed anything?
Treat it as binding once it takes effect, and work from the dates rather than the signature. The regulations tie the effective date to the later of your renewal date and 21 days after you received the statement, and your existing terms continue until then. If you believe the statement arrived inside that window, raise it with the lender in writing and escalate to its complaints process. This is general information, not legal advice.
Does an automatic renewal hurt my credit or require a new stress test?
No new stress test either way, which is precisely why an automatic renewal is frictionless and easy to drift into. Moving to a new lender at maturity is also exempt, as long as the balance and amortization do not change. A sharper rate elsewhere costs you paperwork, not qualification.
The number that matters
An automatic renewal is not a scam. It is a default, and the default is priced for the lender. The distance between 6.19% and 4.95% on a $528,000 balance is $374.05 a month, $31,365.41 of interest across one term, and an $8,170.80 toll if you notice late. Opening that letter four months early costs nothing.
Rates change monthly. Your inbox should too.
One short email when the market moves — Bank of Canada decisions, bond yields, and what they mean for your renewal.
We email you once to confirm. Nothing is sent until you click it.